These days World War I is a forgotten war, living in the shadow of its offspring World War II, even though it was really the first world war that, in many ways, began to shape warfare into something like its modern form. It was a conflict that left its mark on a generation and then some — the War to End All Wars, as it was thought then — and though that prediction has turned out to be sadly incorrect, it certainly managed to affect the wars that came after it. I’m always surprised there aren’t more movies made in this setting, since it requires no exaggeration to create a powerfully dramatic tale.
In Their War, a short film from writer / director Max Mason, the bare facts are more than enough to entice you into the story. Two men, on opposite sides of this vast conflict, do their duty and enlist when their respective countries need them. Nikolaus Seifert (Des Carney), a skilled sniper, hopes to return home to his wife Anna (Elif Knight) with his honor intact despite having fought in a most dishonorable war. Arthur Jefferies (Hamish Riddle) is an ordinary foot soldier who just wants to see his wife Mary (Katharine Orchard) again and their newborn daughter for the first time.
Neither is especially well-suited to life in the trenches — though really, who is? — with one not nearly blindly patriotic enough for his fellow soldiers and the other more than half lost in thoughts of his family. As their lonely paths inevitably converge, the vastness of the war marches on, far beyond the reach of these smaller dramas.
The ending is pitch perfect and unforgettable, not least because this story is only one small example of the many cruelties of war. The immersion into the time period is excellent and the performances absolutely realistic. And beneath it all is the quietly terrible knowledge that no matter what, two families — and the world — will never be the same again.